Автордың құжаттары
0
Басты бет / Заң / Кеден, қаржы және экологиялық құқық / Токтыбеков Темир Абикенович
| Білім беретін мекеме | Квалификация | Аяқталу күні | 
|---|---|---|
| әл-Фараби атынд.ҚазҰУ | Жоғары | 2004 | 
| Файл атауы | Тақырыбы | Сипаттамасы | 
|---|---|---|
-  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    Силлабус  Issues in the Development of Water Legislation  2025-2026
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
-  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
-  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    Интерасктивный силлабус на 2025-2026
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    силлабус
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    Семинары
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    Лекции
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Валюталық құқық  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Қаржы құқығы теориясының мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Теңіз және энергетикалық құқықтағы экологиялық қауіпсіздік  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Теңіз және энергетикалық құқықтағы экологиялық қауіпсіздік  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Теңіз және энергетикалық құқықтағы экологиялық қауіпсіздік  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Теңіз және энергетикалық құқықтағы экологиялық қауіпсіздік  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Теңіз және энергетикалық құқықтағы экологиялық қауіпсіздік  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Атом энергиясын құқықтық реттеу  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Атом энергиясын құқықтық реттеу  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Атом энергиясын құқықтық реттеу  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Атом энергиясын құқықтық реттеу  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Атом энергиясын құқықтық реттеу  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Жер құқығы  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 
                                                                                    SYLLABUS
Fall Semester of the 2025–2026 Academic Year
Educational Program: “6B04205 – Law”
Course ID and Title	Independent Student Work (ISW)	Number of Credits	Total Number of Credits	Independent Student Work under Instructor’s Guidance (ISWIG)
		Дәрістер (Д)	Семинар сабақтар (СС)	Зерт. сабақтар (ЗС)		
2208 Land Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan	98	30	30	-	6	7
ACADEMIC INFORMATION ABOUT THE COURSE
Mode of Instruction	Cycle, Component	Types of Lectures	Types of Seminar Classes	Type and Platform of Final Assessment
Оffline	Basic Disciplines (BD) Elective Component (EC)	Classical Review Analytical Lecture	Logical Tasks
→ Debate / Discussion
→ Crossword Creation
→ Test Questions
	Univer IS Test
Lecturer(s)	Toktybekov Temir Abikenovich	
e-mail:	toktybekov.prok@mail.ru
Phone:	+7 777 2060001	
Assistant(s)		
e-mail:		
Phone:		
ACADEMIC PRESENTATION OF THE COURSE
Course Objective	Expected Learning Outcomes (ELO)
	Indicators of Achieving Expected Learning Outcomes (ELO)
To foster students' ability to have a deep understanding of the land legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, allowing them to respond to the modern labor market and apply it flawlessly in practice.
	1.	Expected Learning Outcome (ELO) for the educational program: Study the formation and development of land legislation in Kazakhstan under market relations.
	1.1 To examine the legal status of the land fund categories of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
		1.2 Learn the skills to apply the knowledge gained during this course in practical work.
	2.	Familiarization with the main concepts, subject, methods of regulation, and sources of land law.
	2.1 Applied the methodology for analyzing the conditions for applying land law norms.
		2.2 Able to explain the conditions for applying specific norms of land law
		2.3 Mastered the analysis of the peculiarities of legislative consolidation of land-legal norms in various practical situations.
	3.	Familiarization with the procedure for obtaining land plots for private ownership according to the current land legislation of Kazakhstan.
	3.1 Able to classify the methods of state regulation of land-legal relations.
		3.2 Able to compare the economic methods of state regulation of land-legal relations.
		Identified the similarities and differences between state regulation and management, and the principles for applying these methods.
	4.	To examine the mechanism of state regulation of land relations in the Republic of Kazakhstan.
	4.1 Knows how to develop measures to ensure land legal legislation.
		4.2 Able to explain the causes of legal violations and ways to prevent and eliminate them.
	5.	To be able to analyze the competencies of government bodies that carry out state regulation of land relations and to distinguish their interrelations.
	5.1 Has mastered justifying the need to apply economic mechanisms for regulating land legal relations.
 
		5.2 Is able to apply the experience of foreign countries in the field of regulating land legal relations.
Prerequisites
	GP2207 Civil Law,
Postrequisites
	PP4312 Business Law, VP3310 Water Law.
Learning resources
	Learning Resources
1. Main Literature
Erkinbayeva, L. K., & Aigarinova, G. T. (2010). Land Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Study Guide. General and Special Sections. Almaty: Zheti Zhargy.
Stamkulov, A. S., & Stamkulova, G. A. (2005). Land Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Almaty.
2. Additional Literature
Bekisheva, S. D. (2009). Environmental Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan: Study Guide. Karaganda: Arko.
Aigarina, G. T., & Dzhangabulova, G. T. (2018). Environmental Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Almaty: Kazakh University Publishing House.
Aigarina, G. T. (2020). Environmental Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan in diagrams. Almaty: Kazakh University Publishing House.
Internet Resources
http://elibrary.kaznu.kz/ru
https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/
https://blog.agrokebety.com/ponyatiye-agrarnogo-prava
Academic Policy of the Course	Academic Policy.
The academic policy is defined by the Academic Policy and the Academic Integrity Policy of Al-Farabi Kazakh National University. These documents are available on the main page of Univer IS.
	Integration of Science and Education.
The scientific research work of students, master’s, and doctoral students represents the deepening of the educational process. It is directly organized in departments, laboratories, the university’s scientific and project divisions, and student scientific-technical associations. Independent work of learners at all levels of education is aimed at developing research skills and competencies based on the acquisition of new knowledge through the use of modern research and information technologies. A research university professor integrates the results of scientific research into lectures and seminars (practical classes), laboratory classes, syllabi, and assignments for IWST (independent work of a student with a teacher) and IWS (independent work of a student), ensuring the relevance of lesson topics and tasks.
Class attendance.
Each assignment’s deadline is indicated in the course calendar (schedule). Failure to meet deadlines will result in a loss of points.
	Academic Integrity.
Practical/laboratory classes and independent work develop a learner’s independence, critical thinking, and creativity. Plagiarism, falsification, use of cheat sheets, and copying at any stage of assignment completion are strictly prohibited. During the theoretical training period and examinations, maintaining academic integrity is a core policy and is additionally regulated by documents such as the “Regulations on Conducting Final Assessments”, “Guidelines for Conducting the Final Assessments of the Current Academic Year’s Fall/Spring Semester”, and the “Regulations on Checking for Copying of Students’ Test Documents”.
	Main Principles of Inclusive Education.
The university’s educational environment is designed as a safe space where instructors and peers always provide support and equal treatment to all learners, regardless of gender, race/ethnic origin, religious beliefs, socio-economic status, physical health, and other factors. Everyone needs the support and friendship of their peers and classmates. For all students, success is defined not by what is impossible, but by what they are capable of achieving. Diversity strengthens all aspects of life.
All learners, especially persons with disabilities, can receive counseling assistance via:
87772060001 toktybekov.prok@mail.ru, https://us04web.zoom.us/j/4175819644?pwd=UWFtS0hicFVick5vaE5WSy83WUVxZz09
https://teams.live.com/l/invite/FEAOhRY5m0bHxAnbQE
	MOOC Integration (Massive Open Online Course).
When MOOCs are integrated into the course, all students are required to register for the MOOC. The deadlines for completing MOOC modules must be strictly followed in accordance with the course schedule.
Attention!
Each assignment deadline is indicated both in the course calendar and in the MOOC. Failure to meet deadlines will result in a loss of points.
	
INFORMATION ON EDUCATION, LEARNING, AND EVALUATION
 
Block-rating letter grading system for calculating academic achievements
	 (Methods of assessment)
Rate
	 (Numerical equivalent of points)
	Scores as a percentage (%)
	(Grade in the traditional system)
	Based on your text, here is the English translation:
________________________________________
Criterial Assessment
Criterial assessment is the process of correlating the actual learning outcomes with the expected learning outcomes based on clearly defined criteria. It is based on formative and summative assessment.
Formative assessment is a type of assessment conducted during daily learning activities. It serves as a current indicator and ensures immediate feedback between the student and the instructor. It helps to identify the student's abilities, pinpoint difficulties, assist in achieving the best results, and allows the instructor to make timely adjustments to the educational process. The performance of assignments and active participation in class are evaluated during lectures, seminars, and practical sessions (discussions, quizzes, debates, round tables, lab work, etc.). The knowledge and competencies acquired are assessed.
Summative assessment is a type of assessment conducted after completing a section in accordance with the subject syllabus. It is carried out 3-4 times throughout the semester when students are completing their independent assignments. This assessment evaluates the mastery of the expected learning outcomes against descriptors. It allows for the determination and recording of the level of mastery of the subject over a specific period. The learning outcomes are assessed.
A	4,0	95-100	Excellent
	
A-	3,67	90-94		
B+	3,33	85-89	Good	
B	3,0	80-84		Formative and Summative Assessment	 (Scores in percentage)
B-	2,67	75-79		(Activity in lectures)
	
C+	2,33	70-74		 (Work during practical classes)
	30
C	2,0	65-69	Satisfactory
	 (Independent work)
	30
D+	1,33	55-59		Final control (exam)	40
D	1,0	50-54		SUM.
100
FX	0,5	25-49	Unsatisfactory
	
F	0	0-24		
Calendar (schedule) for the implementation of the content of the academic course. Methods of teaching and education.
week	Subject Title
	Number of hours
	Maximum score
МОDULE 1: The Concept and Subject of Land Law
1	Module 1: The Subject, Principles, and System of Land Law.
General characteristics of land law: concept, subject matter, and methods of legal regulation. The concept and content of land legal relations.
	1	
	1.	СС Tasks of land legislation. Objectives of land legislation. Principles of land legislation. System of land law.	2	7
2	D 2. Development of Land Relations in Kazakhstan. Land Relations in Sovereign Kazakhstan. The Development of Land Relations in the Republic of Kazakhstan in accordance with Market Demands.	1	
	СЗ 2. Land Relations in Kazakhstan before Joining Russia. Land Relations in Kazakhstan during its Time as a Part of Russia. Land Relations during the Soviet Period. Land Relations in Sovereign Kazakhstan. The Development of Land Relations in the Republic of Kazakhstan in Accordance with Market Demands.	2	7
	Advice on completing SOW 1.		
3	D 3. General Characteristics and Types of Sources of Land Law. Features of Normative Acts as a Source of Law. Classification of Sources of Land Law. Development Prospects for Land Legislation in the Republic of Kazakhstan.	1	
 
	CC 3. Classification of Sources of Land Law. The Land Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan adopted on June 20, 2003, as the main source of land law. The role of court practice in regulating land relations. Development prospects for land legislation in the Republic of Kazakhstan.	2	7
	Independent work 1. You need to provide a general overview of the Land Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan and pay attention to the basic terms used in the Code.
Format: Oral presentation.
Week: Weeks 3 and 4.		25
4	Д 4. Right of Land Ownership: Concept, Types, and Procedures for Implementation. The concept, content, and features of the right of land ownership and other property rights. Types of land ownership: state and private ownership. Subjects of the right of land ownership.	1	
	СС 4. Procedures for Determining Land Share. Composition of the land fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The mechanism for exercising the right of ownership to a land plot. Content of the right of ownership to a land plot. Grounds for the emergence, change, and termination of the right of land ownership.	2	7
5	Д 5. Right of Land Use and Other Land Rights. The concept and types of the right of land use. The difference between the right of land use and the right of land ownership. Subjects of the right of land use and their classification. Pledge (mortgage) of a land plot and the right of land use.	1	
	СС 5. The concept and legal regime of service land plots. The concept and emergence of a servitude. Types of servitudes. Pledge (mortgage) of a land plot and the right of land use..	2	7
6	D 6. Grounds for the emergence, change, and termination of land ownership and other rights. Features of land transactions. (PROBLEM-BASED LECTURE)
Legal facts as grounds for the emergence, change, and termination of land ownership and other rights. Grounds for the emergence of state, private, and use rights to land. Termination of land ownership and use rights. Compensation for damages caused to land owners and land users. Seizure of a land plot.	1	
	СС 6. Other grounds for the termination of the right of ownership and other rights to a land plot. The basis for payment for land. Basic rates for land plots and the cadastral/appraisal value of a land plot. Pledge (mortgage) of a land plot. Lease of a land plot. Exchange of land plots.	2	7
	SOEW 2. Advice on completing SIW 2.		
7	D 7. System of State Regulation Bodies for Land Relations. The concept of the legal mechanism for state regulation of land relations. The system of state regulation bodies for land relations: general and special competence bodies. General competence bodies. The competence of the Government in regulating land relations. The competence of local executive and representative bodies in regulating land relations. Special competence bodies. The competence of the special central competent body in the field of regulating land relations. The Agency for Land Resources Management and its relationship with other environmental protection bodies. The competence of other ministries in the field of regulating land relations.	1	
	СС 7. Special Competence Bodies. The competence of the special central competent body in the field of regulating land relations. The Agency for Land Resources Management and its relationship with other environmental protection bodies. The competence of other ministries in the field of regulating land relations.	2	8
	Independent work 2. Mastering specific types of state regulation functions for land relations.
Review each function in detail.
Format: Essay and presentation.		25
Midterm exam 1	100
Module 2: Specific Categories of Land	
8	D 8. System of Functions of State Bodies in the Field of Land Relations Regulation. The concept of land management, its functions, tasks, stages of the land management process, and its content. Payment for land. Tax benefits on land. Resolution of land disputes. The concept of land monitoring, its structure, and content. The concept of a land cadastre, land-cadastral documents, and the procedure for maintaining a cadastre. The procedure for the state to grant and seize a land plot.	1	
	СС 8. Seminar class. System of functions of state bodies in the field of land relations regulation. The concept of land management, its functions, tasks, stages of the land management process, and its content. Payment for land. Tax benefits on land. Resolution of land disputes. The concept of land monitoring, its structure, and content. The concept of a land cadastre, land-cadastral documents, and the procedure for maintaining a cadastre. The procedure for the state to grant and seize a land plot.	2	6
 
			
	Advice on completing SIW 3.		
9	D 9. The concept of legal protection of land. The concept, types, and elements of land offenses. The priority of protecting agricultural lands. State legal measures for land protection. The concept of liability for land offenses. Types of legal liability for violating land legislation.	1	
	СС 9. The concept of legal protection of land. The concept, types, and elements of land offenses. The priority of protecting agricultural lands. State legal measures for land protection. The concept of liability for land offenses. Types of legal liability for violating land legislation.	2	6
	Subject, form of completion, and submission:
According to the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, ensure obligations.
Form: Oral.		10
10	D 10. Legal status of agricultural lands. The concept and general characteristics of the legal status of agricultural lands. The composition of agricultural lands. The right of private ownership of agricultural lands.	1	
	СС 10. Specifics of granting agricultural lands to foreign citizens and legal entities. The procedure for converting agricultural lands from one type to another. The procedure and grounds for compensating for damages incurred in agricultural production.
	2	6
	Advice on completing Independent Work 4.		
11	D 11. Legal status of settlements' land. The concept and composition of land in settlements. The procedure for designating and changing the boundaries of cities, towns, and villages for their intended use. The concept and composition of land for construction. The legal status of public-use land.	1	
	СС 11. The concept and composition of land in settlements. The procedure for designating and changing the boundaries of cities, towns, and villages for their intended use. The concept and composition of land for construction. The legal status of public-use land.	2	6
12	Д 12. Legal status of lands designated for industry, transport, communication, defense, and other non-agricultural purposes. The concept and composition of lands for industry, transport, communication, defense, and other non-agricultural purposes. The procedure for granting and using lands in this category. Features of the legal status of industrial lands. Specifics of using lands granted for the extraction and processing of minerals. Features of the legal status of lands granted for defense needs. Specially designated zones.	1	
	СС 12. The concept and composition of lands for industry, transport, communication, defense, and other non-agricultural purposes. The procedure for granting and using lands in this category. Features of the legal status of industrial lands. Specifics of using lands granted for the extraction and processing of minerals. Features of the legal status of lands granted for defense needs. Specially designated zones.	2	6
	SOW 4. Compensation for environmental damage, solving situational problems in a practical format.		10
13	D 13. Legal Status of Lands in Specially Protected Natural Areas. The concept of lands in specially protected natural areas. Laws on lands in specially protected natural areas. The concept of lands for reserves, national dendrological and zoological parks, botanical gardens, nature reserves, and natural monuments. Specifics of the legal status of reserve lands. Specifics of the legal status of national dendrological and zoological parks.	1	
	СЗ 13. Legal Status of Lands in Specially Protected Natural Areas. The concept of lands in specially protected natural areas. Laws on lands in specially protected natural areas. The concept of lands for reserves, national dendrological and zoological parks, botanical gardens, nature reserves, and natural monuments. Specifics of the legal status of reserve lands. Specifics of the legal status of national dendrological and zoological parks.	2	6
	
14	D 14. Legal Status of Forest Fund Lands, Water Fund Lands, and Reserve Lands.
The concept and composition of forest fund lands. Management of forest fund lands.	1	
 
	Specifics. The procedure and conditions for temporary use of forest fund lands for agricultural purposes. The procedure for the seizure of forest fund lands. The concept, types, and legal status of water fund lands. The legal status of coastal lands. The legal status of lands in special and protected areas.		
	СС 14. Seminar Session: The Legal Status of Forest, Water, and Reserve Lands
Concepts and Composition of Forest Fund Lands. Special features of managing forest fund lands. The procedure and conditions for the temporary use of forest fund lands for agricultural purposes. The procedure for the seizure of forest fund lands.
The Legal Status of Water Fund Lands. The concept, types, and legal status of water fund lands. The legal status of coastal lands.
The Legal Status of Lands in Special and Protected Areas. The legal status of lands located within special and protected areas.	2	6
	Student's Independent Work 5"
Comparison of foreign and KR (Kazakhstan Republic) legislation (summary).		30
15	D 15. Legal Relations of the Republic of Kazakhstan with CIS Countries in the Field of Land Relations Regulation. Bilateral agreements, procedure for resolving disputes. Participation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in international organizations, international conventions, and environmental protection programs. The UN Convention to Combat Desertification (1994).	1	
	СС 15. Legal Relations of the Republic of Kazakhstan with CIS Countries in the Field of Land Relations Regulation. Bilateral agreements, procedure for resolving disputes. Participation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in international organizations, international conventions, and environmental protection programs. The UN Convention to Combat Desertification (1994). Specifics of legal regulation of land relations in individual states.
	2	8
Midterm Exam 2	100
Final control (exam)	100
Total for the subject.	100
Dean 										U.A. Akhatov
                                                         
Head of Department								G.A. Kuanalieva
Chairwoman of the Academic Committee on Education
and Quality of Education:				                                        A.A. Urisbayeva
Lecturer:									T.A.Toktybekov
 
Criteria for Summative Assessment
The rubric defines the criteria for summative assessment. 
These assessment criteria are used to measure learning outcomes.
«Written assignment on the topic "Land Legal Relations in the Republic of Kazakhstan" (25% of the total AB 100%).
Criteria	«Excellent» 
20–25%	«Good»
15–20%	«Satisfactory» 
10–15%	«Unsatisfactory»
0-10%
Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations	Deep understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Limited understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Superficial understanding or misunderstanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are not provided.
Understanding of key issues of land law and legal relations	Makes strong connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are excellently supported with evidence from empirical research (e.g., based on comparative legal or statistical analysis).	Makes connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are reinforced with evidence from empirical research.	Limited connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Limited use of evidence from empirical research.	Little or no connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Uses little or no evidence from empirical research.
Policy proposals or practical recommendations	Provides well-founded political and/or practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan.	Provides some political and/or practical recommendations for improving state regulation of the agricultural sector and land relations in Kazakhstan.	Provides limited political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan. Recommendations are of little importance, not based on thorough analysis, and are superficial.	Political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan are few, absent, or of very low quality.
Writing,
 APA style	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Strictly follows APA style.	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Mostly follows APA style.	There are some major errors in writing, and clarity needs improvement. Contains mistakes in following APA style.	The writing is unclear, and it is difficult to follow the content. There are many mistakes in following the APA style.
 
Written assignment on «Land ownership rights in the Republic of Kazakhstan» (25% of the total AB 100%).
Criteria	«Excellent»
20-25 %	«Good»
15-20%	«Satisfactory»
10-15%	«Unsatisfactory»
0-10%
Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations	Deep understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to key sources are provided.	Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to key sources are provided.	Limited understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to key sources are provided.	Superficial understanding or misunderstanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) are not provided.
Awareness of key issues in land law and legal relations	Strong ability to compare legislation in the field of land law in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Excellent justification of arguments with empirical research evidence (e.g., based on comparative legal or statistical analysis).	Ability to compare legislation in the field of land law in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are reinforced with empirical research evidence.	Limited ability to connect comparisons of legislation in the field of land law in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Limited use of empirical research evidence.	Little or no ability to connect comparisons of legislation in the field of land law in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Minimal or no use of empirical research evidence.
Policy proposal or practical recommendations
	Provides well-founded political and/or practical recommendations and suggestions regarding land law and state regulation of land relations in Kazakhstan.	Provides some political and/or practical recommendations and suggestions for improving the agricultural sector and state regulation of land relations in Kazakhstan.	Provides limited political and practical recommendations regarding land law and state regulation of land relations in Kazakhstan. Recommendations are not significant, not well-analyzed, and shallow.	Provides few or no political and practical recommendations regarding land law and state regulation of land relations in Kazakhstan, or recommendations are of very poor quality.
Writing,
APA style	Writing demonstrates clarity, accuracy, and correctness. Strictly follows APA style.	Writing demonstrates clarity, accuracy, and correctness. Mostly follows APA style.	Writing contains some major errors and needs improvement in clarity. There are errors in following APA style.	Writing is unclear and difficult to follow. There are many errors in following APA style.
 
Written assignment on «The legal status of certain land plots in the Republic of Kazakhstan» (25% of the total AB 100%).
Criteria	«Excellent» 
20–25%	«Good»
15–20%	«Satisfactory» 
10–15%	«Unsatisfactory»
0-10%
Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations	Deep understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Limited understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Superficial understanding or misunderstanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are not provided.
Understanding of key issues of land law and legal relations	Makes strong connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are excellently supported with evidence from empirical research (e.g., based on comparative legal or statistical analysis).	Makes connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are reinforced with evidence from empirical research.	Limited connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Limited use of evidence from empirical research.	Little or no connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Uses little or no evidence from empirical research.
Policy proposals or practical recommendations	Provides well-founded political and/or practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan.	Provides some political and/or practical recommendations for improving state regulation of the agricultural sector and land relations in Kazakhstan.	Provides limited political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan. Recommendations are of little importance, not based on thorough analysis, and are superficial.	Political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan are few, absent, or of very low quality.
Writing,
APA style	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Strictly follows APA style..	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Mostly follows APA style.	There are some major errors in writing, and clarity needs improvement. Contains mistakes in following APA style.	The writing is unclear, and it is difficult to follow the content. There are many mistakes in following the APA style.
 
Written assignment on "International cooperation in the field of land legal relations in the Republic of Kazakhstan" (25% of the total AB 100%).
Criteria	«Excellent» 
20–25%	«Good»
15–20%	«Satisfactory» 
10–15%	«Unsatisfactory»
0-10%
Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations	Deep understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Limited understanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are provided.	Superficial understanding or misunderstanding of theories and concepts of land law and legal relations. Proper and relevant references (citations) to main sources are not provided.
Understanding of key issues of land law and legal relations	Makes strong connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are excellently supported with evidence from empirical research (e.g., based on comparative legal or statistical analysis).	Makes connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Arguments are reinforced with evidence from empirical research.	Limited connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Limited use of evidence from empirical research.	Little or no connections in comparing legislation in the field of land law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Uses little or no evidence from empirical research.
Policy proposals or practical recommendations	Provides well-founded political and/or practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan.	Provides some political and/or practical recommendations for improving state regulation of the agricultural sector and land relations in Kazakhstan.	Provides limited political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan. Recommendations are of little importance, not based on thorough analysis, and are superficial.	Political and practical recommendations on state regulation of land relations in the field of land law in Kazakhstan are few, absent, or of very low quality.
Writing,
APA style	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Strictly follows APA style.	Writing demonstrates clarity, precision, and correctness. Mostly follows APA style.	There are some major errors in writing, and clarity needs improvement. Contains mistakes in following APA style.	The writing is unclear, and it is difficult to follow the content. There are many mistakes in following the APA style.
                                                                                 
                                                                             | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 | 
                                                                        |
Су заңнамасын дамыту мәселелері  | 
                                                                                
                                                                                 |